光学学报, 2015, 35 (8): 0825001, 网络出版: 2015-07-29
光电器件的CRLB 特性及定位技术的误差比较
CRLB Feature of Optoelectronic Device and a Comparison of the Locating Errors for Centroiding Algorithms
光电子学光器件 质心法 迭代加权质心法 最小二乘高斯拟合法 定位误差 最小方差无偏 星敏感器 optoelectronics optoelectronic devices center of gravity iteratively weighted center of gravity Gaussian least squares fitting locating error minimum variance unbiased star tracker
摘要
含有噪声的光电成像器件定位过程中,Cramer-Rao Lower Bound(CRLB)被用来计算器件的定位精度,作为任何无偏估计的下限,CRLB可作为判据评估定位技术是否满足最小方差无偏(MVU)特性.本文给出了成像器件在泊松和高斯噪声下的CRLB 特性,并据此研究质心法(COG)、迭代加权质心法(IWCOG)、最小二乘高斯拟合法(GLSF)的定位误差.理论分析和仿真验证均表明,IWCOG 和GLSF定位误差与光电成像器件的CRLB相同,满足MVU 特性,而COG 定位误差最大;COG 耗时最少,GLSF最耗时不能在轨应用而IWCOG 用时仅比COG 高几倍.充分证明迭代加权质心法具有低误差、实时和鲁棒特性,因而适用于星敏感器、Shack-Hartmann传感器波前定位等高精度定位场合.
Abstract
In the positioning procedure for point- like sources generated in optoelectronic devices,Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB) is used to estimate the locating accuracy of the devices contaminated with noise.As the lower bound of any unbiased estimator,CRLB is known as a criterion to assess whether an estimator meets the characteristics of minimum variance unbiased (MVU).The CRLB characteristies on the performance of the imaging device under both Poisson and Gaussian noise are given and accordingly the positioning error of three current centroiding algorithms,center of gravity (COG),iteratively weighted center of gravity (IWCOG) and Gaussian least squares fitting(GLSF),is investigated respectively.Theoretical analysis and simulation results show that IWCOG and GLSF share the same position error and reach CRLB of optoelectronic imaging device,thus meet MVU features.That is to say,COG makes the biggest positioning error,followed by IWCOG and GLSF.And the computing time of IWCOG is just several times longer than COG algorithm,while GLSF algorithm is certainly the time-consuming procedure to make it inapplicable on-board on star tracker.IWCOG is proven to be as a method with low error,real- time and robust algorithm,making it possible for highprecision condition such as star tracker,Shack-Hartmann sensor.
张俊, 郝云彩, 龙也, 刘达. 光电器件的CRLB 特性及定位技术的误差比较[J]. 光学学报, 2015, 35(8): 0825001. Zhang Jun, Hao Yuncai, Long Ye, Liu Da. CRLB Feature of Optoelectronic Device and a Comparison of the Locating Errors for Centroiding Algorithms[J]. Acta Optica Sinica, 2015, 35(8): 0825001.