光谱学与光谱分析, 2018, 38 (9): 2888, 网络出版: 2018-10-02  

基于Fisher判别分析与随机森林的马尾松毛虫害检测

Dendrolimus Punctatus Walker Damage Detection Based on Fisher Discriminant Analysis and Random Forest
作者单位
1 福州大学环境与资源学院, 福建 福州 350116
2 福建省资源环境监测与可持续经营利用重点实验室, 福建 三明 365004
3 空间数据挖掘与信息共享教育部重点实验室, 福建 福州 350116
4 福建省水土流失遥感监测评估与灾害防治重点实验室, 福建 福州 350116
5 福建省南平市延平区林业局, 福建 南平 353000
6 厦门市森林病虫害防治检疫站, 福建 厦门 361004
摘要
虫害检测算法的构建是耦合“地—天”特征的过程, 是实现其遥感监测的重要保障。 以福建省三明市、 将乐县、 沙县、 南平市延平区等4个县(区、 市)为试验区, 收集182组马尾松毛虫害样本数据, 随机划分为训练集与验证集, 设置5次重复试验及1次指标筛除试验。 结合马尾松毛虫危害下的寄主表征, 获取松林叶面积指数LAI、 叶面积指数标准误SEL、 归一化差值植被指数NDVI、 缨帽变换湿度轴WET及影像绿光波段B2、 红光波段B3、 近红外波段B4等7个地面与遥感特征指标, 建立其危害等级的Fisher判别分析与随机森林模型, 从检测精度、 Kappa系数、 ROC曲线等角度综合比较两种算法的检测效果, 并给予配对t检验。 结果表明: 7个指标均具备虫害响应能力, SEL和NDVI相对较弱; Fisher判别分析6次试验的虫害平均检测精度为73.26%, Kappa系数为0.631 9, 而RF法则分别为79.30%, 0.715 1, 显著优于前者(p<0.05); RF法对无危害、 轻度危害、 中度危害3个虫害等级的检测精度、 Kappa系数、 AUC均显著高于Fisher判别分析(p<0.05), 对于重度危害等级, Fisher判别分析则占优。 总体而言, RF法对马尾松毛虫害的检测效果优于Fisher判别分析, 但Fisher判别分析对重度危害等级有更高准确性且模型明确、 易于推广, 可综合应用两种算法开展虫害监测工作。 该成果为马尾松毛虫害及其他森林病虫害的有效检测提供技术参考, 奠定其遥感监测的基础。
Abstract
The construction of the pest detection algorithm is a process of coupling the “ground-space” features, which is an important guarantee to realize its remote sensing monitoring. Taking Sanming City, Jiangle County, Sha County and Yanping District in Nanping City in Fujian Province as the experimental areas, it gathered 182 samples of Dendrolimus punctatus Walker damage and randomly divided them into training set and validation set, and 5 repeated tests and 1 test of index screening were performed. According the host representations damaged by Dendrolimus punctatus Walker, 7 ground and remote sensing characteristic indices including pine forest leaf area index (LAI), standard deviation of LAI (SEL), normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), wetness from tasseled cap transformation (WET), green band (B2), red band (B3), near infrared band (B4) were obtained, then the models of Fisher discriminant analysis and random forest for pest levels were constructed. The detection precision, Kappa coefficient and ROC curve were used to comprehensively compare the detection effects of these two algorithms, as well as the paired t-test. The results showed that all the 7 indices have the pest responsiveness, while SEL and NDVI are relatively weak; the average detection precision of Fisher discriminant analysis in 6 tests was 73.26%, Kappa coefficient was 0.631 9, and 79.30%, 0.715 1 of RF respectively, indicating RF is significantly better than the former one (p<0.05); for the 3 pest levels of non-damage, mild damage and moderate damage, the detection precision, Kappa coefficient and AUC of RF were all significantly higher than Fisher discriminant analysis (p<0.05), while for the severe damage, Fisher was better. On the whole, the Dendrolimus punctatus Walker damage detection effect of RF is better than Fisher discriminant analysis, but Fisher has more accurate for the severe damage and the mode is clear, easy to by promoted, so these two algorithms could be comprehensively utilized to put forward the pest monitoring work. The results can provide a technical reference for the effective detection of Dendrolimus punctatus Walker damage as well as other forest pests and diseases, and lay a foundation of the remote sensing monitoring.

许章华, 黄旭影, 林璐, 王前锋, 刘健, 陈崇成, 余坤勇, 周华康, 张华峰. 基于Fisher判别分析与随机森林的马尾松毛虫害检测[J]. 光谱学与光谱分析, 2018, 38(9): 2888. XU Zhang-hua, HUANG Xu-ying, LIN Lu, WANG Qian-feng, LIU Jian, CHEN Chong-cheng, YU Kun-yong, ZHOU Hua-kang, ZHANG Hua-feng. Dendrolimus Punctatus Walker Damage Detection Based on Fisher Discriminant Analysis and Random Forest[J]. Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis, 2018, 38(9): 2888.

关于本站 Cookie 的使用提示

中国光学期刊网使用基于 cookie 的技术来更好地为您提供各项服务,点击此处了解我们的隐私策略。 如您需继续使用本网站,请您授权我们使用本地 cookie 来保存部分信息。
全站搜索
您最值得信赖的光电行业旗舰网络服务平台!