IEEE禁止华为员工担任审稿人或编辑?!有IEEE的会员和期刊编委声明退出编委会
今日上午,一封似IEEE向期刊主编发送的内部邮件中表示:禁止华为员工担任审稿人或编辑。
IEEE(Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers),国际电气与电子工程师协会,当今世界电子、电气、计算机、通信、自动化工程技术研究领域最著名、规模最大的非营利性跨国学术组织。
邮件内容如下:
清华大学计算机科学与技术系助理研究员刘知远认为,如果一直这样对抗下去,以后全球会出现双备份的国际学术组织,学术期刊,学术会议,技术标准等等等等。
南京大学周志华教授表示这是赤裸裸的干涉,IEEE只是在美国注册。建议圈内IEEE各级管理层的专家向IEEE提议改到瑞士之类去注册。更重要的是,大家多支持国内优秀期刊(不仅中文期刊,尤其是国内出版的英文国际期刊),例如《中国科学:信息科学》、计算机的《FCS》、综合的《NSR》等。
IEEE的会员和期刊编委张海霞更发布声明:
今日惊闻IEEE下令禁止华为专家参与期刊审稿,这远远超出了一个可以接受学术人的底线,做为IEEE的会员和期刊编委,我必须表明自己的态度:我申请退出我所在的两个IEEE期刊的编委会,并给IEEE候任主席写了一封公开信。这是我个人的态度,与任何其他组织和个人无关,特此声明。
张海霞︱致IEEE主席的公开信
Dear Prof. Toshio Fukuda (the IEEE Presidentas-elected),
This is Haixia Zhangfrom Peking University, as an old friend and senior IEEE member, I am really shocked to hear that IEEE is involved in "US-Huawei Ban" for replacing all reviewers from Huawei, which is far beyond the basic line of Science and Technology which I was trainedand am following in my professional career till now.
I joined IEEE since I were a Ph.D student because it is recognized as an International professional academic platform in Electronics Engineering relative areas by my colleagues, friends worldwide. During last 20 years, I worked with many scientists like you together in IEEE societies, journals, conferences, events, for example, last year during your election as the first president of IEEE from Asian(maybe), because we all believe that IEEE is an international society, not just belong to USA or north America area or some parties, its members cover all over the world and everyone has equal right to make it more professional, productive with high efficiency.
But, today, this message from IEEE for “replacing all reviewers from Huawei in IEEE journals” is challenging my professional integrity. I have to say that, As a professor, I AM NOT accept this. Therefore, I decided to quit from IEEE NANO andIEEE JEMS editorial board untill one day it come back to our common professional integrity.
Pleasepass this letter to IEEE office and responsible officers.
Looking for the daylight.
Haixia Zhang, Professor, Peking University
May 29th, 2019
——reads
在此之前,5月23日美国埃默里大学内部公开解雇两位华人学者,原因是“李晓江和李世华未充分公开来自国外的研究经费,以及在中国研究机构和大学工作的范围”(through the course of an investigation prompted by an NIH inquiry, Emory determined that these faculty members had failed to fully disclose foreign sources of research funding and the extent of their work for research institutions and universities in China)
来源:稀有金属材料与工程